Notes by Vince.

Just after the breakthrough into An Unexpected Development in
August 2018, we’d had a discussion regarding the possible origins of the cave
system along with other geomorphological processes and events, i.e. Pleistocene
frost and ice damage. At the time I started to put together the following

Notes on geomorphology. Is there a
hypogenic origin for Hallowe’en Rift?

Cave development can occur in deep-seated conditions, without
direct recharge from the surface, by recharge to the cave-forming zone coming
from depth. This type of speleogenesis is termed hypogenic (or hypogene).
The concept of hypogene speleogenesis does not necessarily mean cave
development at great depth but refers to the origin of the cave-forming agency
from depth. Hypogene speleogenesis is defined as the formation of
solution-enlarged permeability structures by water that recharges the cavernous
zone from below, independent of recharge from the overlying or immediately
adjacent surface.

The following elementary cave patterns are typical (although not
necessarily exclusive) for hypogene speleogenesis:

Single passages or rudimentary networks of passages;

Cavernous edging along transverse hypogene conduits;

Network maze;

Sponge-work maze;

Irregular isolated chambers;

Rising, steeply inclined passages or shafts;

Collapse shafts over large hypogenic voids and breccia pipes.

Network maze caves of hypogene origin are known in limestones,
dolomites and gypsum, in mixed limestone-dolomite-gypsum strata, and in
conglomerates. A common feature of network mazes is a very high passage

Rising, steeply inclined passages or shafts are outlets of deep
hypogene systems in which the “root” structure remains unknown in most cases.
Possibly formed by rising thermal waters charged with CO2 and H2S.

Composite 3D systems are comprised of various elementary patterns
at different levels, such as irregular chambers, clusters of network or
sponge-work mazes and rising, subvertical conduits and other morphs connecting

Hypogenic features may become relict but still, remain within
contemporary systems, for example, in a system where original confinement was
breached and the flow pattern reversed from upwelling to descending (Klimchouk,

Alexander Klimchouk. Speleogenesis, Hypogenic in The Encyclopaedia of Caves.
Elsevier, 2012, p748-765

Nick made the following comments (first reported 21/08/2018):

polished nature of the dolomitic conglomerates was noted throughout most of the
cave with hard limestone/dolomitic pebbles and crystalline red marl matrix
having been eroded equally. This erosion pattern is in marked contrast to
the dolomitic conglomerates in Home Close where the softer matrix is eroded
preferentially compared to the limestone pebbles that stick out as knobbly
lumps. The polished erosion pattern is consistent with a base of a
streamway or a passage full of water as opposed to slow dripping of water. As
similar polished conglomerates are clearly seen down the new pitch, as well as
in the roofs of the horizontal passages which are phreatic in shape and have
well developed scalloping, the logical conclusion is that water that initially
formed the pitch was upward flowing. Undoubtedly there has been a limited
amount of inflow from above later in the history of this cave’s development but
it is relatively insignificant in terms of passage dimensions although highly
significant for the development of the formations.”

Duncan and Tav also made some valid comments noted while carrying out
a survey of the cave.

These thoughts might be more salient following a recent paper by
Smart and McArdle published in the UBSS Proceedings Volume 28 (1) 2019,
p65-102, suggesting a hypogenic origin for Denny’s Hole.

It is obvious that further investigation and research is required.